In the world of investing, there’s a common misconception that holding on to stocks indefinitely—especially those with significant gains—is always the best strategy. But what if this mindset is actually costing you money in the long run? What if someone told you that if you sell some stocks strategically could not only protect your wealth but also reduce your future tax burden?
In this article, we’ll explore the concept of tax gain harvesting, how it differs from tax loss harvesting, why delaying sales could leave you with less than you think, and why the right timing in stock sales is more important than ever.
The Myth of Holding Forever
Many investors pride themselves on buying and holding stocks for decades. They believe this patience pays off, especially if they purchased during market lows—like in 2008 or 2009—and saw their investments skyrocket in value. But there’s a catch.
When an investor says, “I bought this stock at $1, and now it’s worth a fortune,” the next question should be, “How much of those gains have you harvested?” Too often, the answer is none.
That’s a problem.
Failing to sell any portion of a highly appreciated stock can turn into a tax and financial management nightmare. People avoid selling because they don’t want to “pay taxes.” But by doing that, they’re locking themselves into a massive, unrealized gain—and potentially missing the opportunity to manage taxes more efficiently over time.
The Danger of Waiting Too Long
Let’s consider a real-world example. Novo Nordisk (NVO), the pharmaceutical company known for producing weight-loss and diabetes medications, saw a dramatic rise in its stock value. However, recently the stock has seen a significant drop.
Those who rode the stock up but never sold are now watching much of their gains vanish. And since they didn’t realize the gain along the way, they can’t benefit from the tax advantages that would’ve come with harvesting.
Here’s the hard truth: If you don’t sell, you haven’t really made a profit. And if the stock crashes, your unrealized gain becomes an unrealized regret.
What Is Tax Gain Harvesting?
Tax gain harvesting is a proactive investment strategy. It involves selling stocks that have appreciated in value to realize capital gains—even if you plan to immediately buy them back.
Why do this?
Because realizing gains increases the cost basis of your investment. This can dramatically reduce the capital gains taxes you’ll owe in the future, especially if you take advantage of current tax brackets.
For example:
- You buy a stock at $10.
- It rises to $20.
- You sell it and pay tax on the $10 gain.
- Then you buy it back at $20.
Now your cost basis is $20. If the stock rises again, your future gains will be taxed from that new, higher base.
“But What About the Taxes?”
This is the most common concern: “I don’t want to pay taxes.”
But here’s a compelling counterpoint: You can often realize up to $90,000 in capital gains per year and pay no tax (depending on your filing status and income). That’s right—zero tax.
Strategic selling lets you take advantage of your current tax bracket, avoid getting trapped by a “tax bomb” later, and keep your portfolio flexible. The key is to act before it’s too late.
Managing Risk and Flexibility
Good financial advisors don’t just watch your portfolio grow. They manage risk, minimize taxes, and ensure flexibility. They don’t let you build oversized positions that become too expensive to unwind.
Selling incrementally:
- Gives you more control.
- Increases your cost basis.
- Reduces emotional attachment.
- Avoids getting trapped by a sudden market downturn or tax burden.
What About 401(k)s?
Tax gain harvesting only applies to after-tax investment accounts, not retirement accounts like 401(k)s or traditional IRAs. Inside retirement accounts, gains aren’t taxed until withdrawal.
The wealthiest investors often face the biggest challenges with after-tax brokerage accounts. Large unrealized gains, dividends they don’t need, and future inheritance taxes can all be major financial pain points.
Visualizing the Tax Burden
Many people vastly underestimate how much tax they’ll pay over the course of retirement.
One real case study involved a $2 million portfolio projected to pay almost $2 million in taxes over retirement. That’s an enormous burden—but with proper planning and strategies like tax gain harvesting, much of that could be avoided.
A Strategic Example: Tax-Efficient Roth Conversion
One high-net-worth couple, living off pension income and spending very little, was able to apply an advanced strategy:
- Their IRA was moved into a program with a 21% upfront bonus and a 3.2% fixed return.
- That gain funded Roth IRA conversions over time—without increasing their tax bracket.
- Once converted, their money was invested aggressively in growth assets, now tax-free forever.
Instead of passing a “tax bomb” to their children, they created a tax-free legacy—something their previous advisors never even suggested.
Tax Gain vs. Tax Loss Harvesting
Let’s clarify something that confuses even seasoned investors: Tax gain harvesting is not the same as tax loss harvesting.
- Tax loss harvesting involves selling stocks at a loss to offset capital gains. Be careful of the wash-sale rule—you can’t buy back the same stock within 30 days.
- Tax gain harvesting is about realizing profits in a controlled, strategic way—and there’s no wash-sale rule to worry about.
So, when you harvest gains, you can sell and rebuy the stock immediately to reset your cost basis.
Start Planning Now—Not During Tax Season
Tax planning isn’t something you should do in April when you’re filing last year’s returns. It needs to happen now—months or even years before you sell a business, take IRA withdrawals, or pass investments to heirs.
Good planning looks ahead. It considers income projections, tax bracket changes, legacy goals, and market trends. And most importantly, it helps you keep more of your money.
Why You Should Sell Some Stocks Before It’s Too Late – Conclusion
It’s tempting to believe that holding your winning stocks forever is the best plan. But smart investors know that realizing gains strategically is just as important as choosing the right stocks.
If you’ve held a stock for years and it has multiplied in value, don’t let fear of taxes stop you from locking in some of those gains. Consider selling part of your position, increasing your cost basis, and reducing future tax burdens.
The earlier you start tax gain harvesting, the more control you’ll have. And if you’re already sitting on large unrealized gains, it’s not too late—but it will be if the market turns and you lose what you’ve built.
Make a plan. Work with professionals who understand advanced tax strategies. And most importantly, don’t wait until it’s too late to act.
If you’re sitting on decades-old stock positions, now is the time to consider whether holding is still the smartest option. Selling isn’t about fear—it’s about strategy. And in today’s environment, strategy is everything.
Also read: Can Tariffs Really Replace the IRS?
About:
Our Channel “ ON THE MONEY“, is powered by Allied Wealth, Houston’s premier wealth management and financial planning firm. On the Money brings viewers educational, topic-driven, and real-life financial scenarios every week.
Topics we will be covering are Retirement and Financial Planning, Investment Selection, Retirement Income Planning, Taxes and Taxation during Retirement, Healthcare, Long Term Care, Legacy and Estate Planning, in addition to important Market and Economic changes impacting Retirement.
Allied Wealth is fully dedicated to your financial future, financial security and retirement.
With Allied Wealth, you will spend less time worrying and more time enjoying the life you’ve earned!
