A rising market often brings with it a sense of security and confidence. Your portfolio seems healthy, your returns are strong, and you feel ready to take on more risk. But the true test of your financial plan—and your emotional readiness—comes when the market takes a dive. If a major market downturn were to happen tomorrow, how would your portfolio hold up? More importantly, how would you hold up?
In this guide, we’re going to explore the often misunderstood concepts of risk tolerance and risk capacity, and why knowing the difference between them could make or break your retirement. We’ll also dig into tools like standard deviation that can help you assess how much loss your portfolio could realistically sustain in a market crash.
Understanding Risk Tolerance: The Emotional Side of Investing
Risk tolerance is a phrase you’ll hear a lot when dealing with financial advisors. It’s usually one of the first things you’re asked to assess when building a portfolio.
You might be handed a clipboard at your advisor’s office, with questions like:
- How long will you need your money to last?
- How would you react if your portfolio dropped 20%?
- Would you buy more, stay put, or sell in panic?
These questions are trying to gauge your emotional response to market volatility. It’s all about how you feel when your money is at risk.
But here’s the kicker: many of us misjudge our own risk tolerance. You might think of yourself as a thrill-seeking investor, but when tested, you might score far more conservatively. One investor thought he’d land in the 80s on a 1-to-99 risk scale—he scored a 53. That’s not uncommon. Our confidence tends to rise when markets are doing well. We say, “I like risk!”—until the losses hit, and panic sets in.
Introducing Risk Capacity: The Reality Check
Now, let’s flip the script.
Risk capacity isn’t about how you feel. It’s about how much risk your portfolio can mathematically take without ruining your long-term plans.
✦ Risk Tolerance = How much risk you think you can handle
✦ Risk Capacity = How much risk you can actually afford to take
This is especially crucial for people at or near retirement. Once you’ve reached the top of the retirement mountain and begin descending (i.e., withdrawing funds), it’s no longer about emotional resilience—it’s about whether your portfolio can physically survive a blow and still support your lifestyle.
So, even if your risk tolerance score says you’re “moderate” or “aggressive,” the more important question is:
Does your current asset allocation align with your risk capacity?
A Simple Math Test: Can You Take the Hit?
Let’s say your portfolio averages a 10% annual return. That sounds great, right? But average returns only tell half the story. What about volatility?
That’s where standard deviation comes in—a measure of how much returns tend to fluctuate above or below the average. Think of it as your portfolio’s “wobble factor.”
Imagine this:
- Your portfolio averages 10% return
- Standard deviation = 15
In a major market crash, portfolios often move three standard deviations below the mean. That’s a potential drop of:
3 × 15 = 45%
So, your 10% portfolio could lose up to 45% in a severe downturn.
Let’s apply that to real money:
- You have a $1 million portfolio
- You’re withdrawing $60,000 a year (6%)
If the market crashes and your portfolio drops 45%, it’s now worth just $550,000. Suddenly, your withdrawal rate becomes unsustainable. What used to be 6% is now nearly 11% of your portfolio—doubling your risk of running out of money.
Why Math Always Wins
When building or adjusting your investment strategy, it’s essential to remember: feelings don’t fund retirement—math does.
You might feel like you can handle aggressive investing. But if your portfolio takes a nosedive and you’re still withdrawing funds, recovery may become impossible. And unlike working years, retirees can’t just “wait it out” or make up for losses with new income.
The lesson? Math wins. Always.
This is where financial planning becomes more than just picking stocks or funds. It becomes a matter of matching your asset allocation not only to your comfort level but to your actual financial needs.
The Counterintuitive Truth About Market Behavior
Here’s another truth that surprises many investors:
We often take more risk when we should be taking less.
As markets rise, people feel more confident and lean toward aggressive strategies. But that’s when risk is highest. Ironically, when markets fall and fear spikes, investors pull back and go conservative—when prices are actually more attractive.
Instead, consider flipping the script:
- Be more conservative when markets are at all-time highs
- Be cautiously aggressive when markets have fallen
This approach helps you protect gains when risk is elevated and seize opportunities when others are selling in panic.
Have You Run the Numbers?
You’ve likely heard advisors talk about “stress testing” your portfolio. It’s not just a buzzword—it’s a crucial exercise.
Ask yourself:
- Have I considered standard deviation?
- Have I estimated my maximum drawdown?
- Have I compared those figures with my withdrawal rate?
If the answer is no, then it might be time to seek a second opinion. Especially if you’re within five years of retirement or already withdrawing income, your investment plan should be reviewed in light of both tolerance and capacity.
What Should You Do Now?
Here’s a simple action plan to help you prepare for the next major downturn:
1. Know Your Risk Tolerance Score
Take a risk assessment quiz, but be honest. Don’t answer based on how you feel when markets are high—answer based on how you felt during past downturns.
2. Calculate Your Risk Capacity
Work with an advisor or use a financial planning tool to determine how much loss you can mathematically take without derailing your retirement plan.
3. Analyze Standard Deviation
Look beyond average returns. Understand the volatility of your portfolio and what it means during extreme market events.
4. Run a Portfolio Stress Test
What would happen if your investments lost 30–45% tomorrow? Would you still be able to retire or continue your lifestyle? Run the numbers—don’t guess.
5. Update Your Withdrawal Strategy
If you’re already in retirement, make sure your withdrawal rate is sustainable, especially in bear markets. You may need to adjust temporarily to protect your principal.
Can Your Portfolio Withstand a Major Market Downturn? – Final Thoughts
Markets go up. Markets go down. That’s the nature of investing. But how you prepare in good times will determine how you survive the bad times.
If your financial advisor has only talked to you about your risk tolerance—but hasn’t analyzed your risk capacity—it might be time for a deeper conversation. Because when the next downturn hits, you won’t be thinking about how you feel. You’ll be thinking about whether your plan still works.
And remember: Math always wins.
Also read: The 3-Bucket Retirement Income Strategy Explained
About:
Our Channel “ ON THE MONEY“, is powered by Allied Wealth, Houston’s premier wealth management and financial planning firm. On the Money brings viewers educational, topic-driven, and real-life financial scenarios every week.
Topics we will be covering are Retirement and Financial Planning, Investment Selection, Retirement Income Planning, Taxes and Taxation during Retirement, Healthcare, Long Term Care, Legacy and Estate Planning, in addition to important Market and Economic changes impacting Retirement.
Allied Wealth is fully dedicated to your financial future, financial security and retirement.
With Allied Wealth, you will spend less time worrying and more time enjoying the life you’ve earned!
